Our website uses cookies to store information on your computer. You may delete and block all cookies from this site, but parts of the site will not work as a result. Find out more about how we use cookies.
(Do not show this message again)
Shout99 - News matters for freelancers
Search Shout99 - News matters for freelancers
(Advanced Search)
   Join Shout99  About Shout99   Sitemap   Contact Shout99 15th Oct 2018
Forgot your password?
Shout99 - Freelancers, FO35, Section 660
New Users Click Here
Shout99 - Freelancers, FO35, Section 660
Shout99 - Freelancers, FO35, Section 660
Front Page
News...
  Business
  IR35
  Political
  Income shifting/S660
  Viewpoint
  IR591
  Agents
  Newsletters
  Shout99 calls
  Links
Freelancers' Shop...
Ask an Expert...
Letters
Direct Contracts
Press Links
Question Time
The Clubhouse
Conference Hall...
News from Partners
Accountants

Login
Sitemap

Business Links

Shout99 - Freelancers, FO35, Section 660

Freelancers' Shop

Personal Financial Services
from ContractorFinancials

Mortgages

Pensions

ISAs

Income protection

... and more special offers for Shout99 readers in the Freelancers' Shop

Shout99 - Freelancers, FO35, Section 660
  
Shout99 - Freelancers, FO35, Section 660

News for the
Construction Industry

Hardhatter.com - News for small businesses in the construction industry

Powered by
Powered by Novacaster
Shout99 has a number of special offers for its readers to help you run your small business (click on red links for more information):
PI insurance
From £98 for freelancers and management consultants
Income protection/PHI
Tailored income protection/PHI insurance for freelancers
Pensions
Online pension finder for freelancers
Banking
Specialist banking service for small businesses and freelancers

Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter
by Susie Hughes at 11:23 11/12/07 (Section 660)
The Government recently outlined its plans to crack down on individuals 'shifting' income between themselves to obtain what HMRC sees as an unfair tax advantage.
This practice had not only been in common use, but at one stage was recommended by one of the Government's small business operations. Now individuals in business together will soon face a complicated assessment of whether income has been 'shifted' and how much income has been 'foregone'.

Andy Vessey from Qdos looks at the scenario.

Andy writes:

Those of us old enough to remember the PG Tips adverts that used chimps to act out humorous scenarios, may recall the scene that involved a ady home owner offering cups of tea to a pair of removal men struggling to haul a piano up the stairs, by calling, “Coo-ee, coo-ee Mr Shifter”. Well HMRC last week served up something that will leave more of a bitter taste in the mouths of businesses, with the publication of their consultation document on the draft legislation on ‘Income Shifting’.

Following their defeat in the House of Lords in the Arctic Systems case this year we knew that proposed legislation was on the horizon to tackle that most heinous of practices involving spouses sharing their income and saving tax along the way!

Legislation
That legislation has now been drafted entitled ‘Income-shifting’ and will be inserted in Part 13 of the Income Tax Act 2007 (tax avoidance) and it deals with how small businesses, run in a partnership or a limited company, are to be taxed as from April 6 2008. Whilst these businesses will normally involve spousal relationships, it will also affect civil partnerships and perhaps co-habiting partners, as the legislation refers to “individuals”.

For the legislation to apply, section 681B requires four conditions, all of which must be met:
(a) Individual 1 has party to, or has power over the relevant arrangements;
(b) Individual 1 forgoes income and the forgone income is individual 2’s for the relevant tax year;
(c) Individual 1 has the power to control the amount that is shifted; and
(d) The shifted income consists of distributions of a company or profits of a partnership.

The legislation will not apply in the following circumstances:

  • To genuine commercial arrangements;
  • Arrangements that are the same as those that would have been entered into in dealing with an unconnected party on an arm’s length basis;
  • Gaining a tax advantage is not the main or one of the main purposes of the arrangements;
  • The individual whose income is shifted has no power to control or influence the amount of income; or
  • Notwithstanding that income shifting has taken place, there is no overall tax advantage.

Suffocate
The legislation has apparently been designed to reflect the realities of running a business and will catch those situations where the second individual is rewarded beyond their participation in a business. Sound familiar?

HMRC believe that only a minority of businesses will be affected but it is thought that some 30,000 small companies may be affected and as SME’s represent over 99 per cent of UK businesses, this legislation could suffocate entrepreneurship.

Advertisement
HMRC have also stated that administrative burdens on business will be minimal and that no additional record keeping will be required. Not for the first time, HMRC are in need of a reality check, given that in the event of any enquiry they may wish to see documentation showing how an individual has arrived at the amount of the income shifted and also records that demonstrates the nature and extent of the work done by individual 2, which may include contracts of employment, time sheets, board minutes, any research done on the market rates of pay for the duties undertaken by individual 2 etc.

Whilst the Government has opened up the legislation for consultation, it is believed that the legislation is fixed and therefore the consultation process will be somewhat restricted.

The legislation will be in addition to the settlements legislation (old Section 660A), so HMRC can potentially have two bites of the cherry in certain circumstances.

The Government seem to believe that husbands and wives go into business together to avoid paying taxes but the reality is somewhat different. Long before there were any tax advantages of spouses sharing income, married couples have been forming businesses together, e.g, Copeman (HMIT) v Coleman (1939) is just one example where a husband and wife held ordinary shares in a limited company.

Qdos are currently in the process of reviewing its TLC660 insurance to consider the effects of this legislation and will make further announcements in due course. We will be doing everything we can to give contractors future peace of mind.

Andy Vessey
Tax Manager
Qdos Consulting

Further information
Shout99 has followed the events relating to Section 660 and income shifting. You can also read more about the background and the issues at stake in Shout99's Section 660 resource centre.
--
If you wish to comment on this article, please log in and use the Reply button below. Registering is free and easy - see 'Join Shout99'.
-
Susie Hughes © Shout99 2007

View Comments (Flat Mode) Printer Version

Mail this to a friend
Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter Susie Hughes - 11/12
    Can I just assume jojo - 11/12
    Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter sand1 - 11/12
       Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter VXJK - 11/12
       Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter rshearer - 11/12
          It's only Tax after all ! brianc - 15/12
       Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter anthonyenglish - 11/12
          Married for Tax Reasons jojo - 12/12
             Re: Married for Tax Reasons Den-ny - 16/12
    Fear not the legislation VXJK - 11/12
       Re: Fear not the legislation jojo - 11/12
          Re: Fear not the legislation skytraveller - 12/12
       Re: Fear not the legislation peteyboy - 13/12
          Re: Fear not the legislation VXJK - 14/12
          Re: Fear not the legislation skytraveller - 14/12
    Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter jtrusc123 - 11/12
       Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter skytraveller - 12/12
          Re: Account in Overdraft chr1s - 14/12
    Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter Den-ny - 11/12
       Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter jojo - 12/12
       Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter Gnashmills - 12/12
    Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter adriant - 11/12
       Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter adriant - 11/12
    Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter asif9876 - 11/12
       Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter adriant - 11/12
          Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter asif9876 - 11/12
          Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter PAULSC - 11/12
          Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter tim - 12/12
             Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter brsltd - 12/12
             Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter adriant - 13/12
                Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter tim - 14/12
                   Justification for opposing the... PAULSC - 14/12
             Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter asif9876 - 13/12
                Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter PAULSC - 13/12
                   Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter skytraveller - 14/12
                Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter burnetts - 13/12
       WHY ??? rshearer - 11/12
          Re: WHY ??? asif9876 - 11/12
             Re: WHY ??? PAULSC - 11/12
                Re: WHY ??? asif9876 - 12/12
                   this is different isn't it? PAULSC - 12/12
                      Re: this is different isn't it... asif9876 - 12/12
                         Re: this is different isn't it... tim - 12/12
                         Re: this is different isn't it... skytraveller - 12/12
                      Re: this is different isn't it... Den-ny - 16/12
                         Re: this is different isn't it... jacksjpt - 17/12
          Re: WHY ??? adriant - 11/12
             Re: WHY ??? asif9876 - 11/12
                YOU are right..its MOST unfair FlyingByte - 11/12
                   Re: YOU are right..its MOST un... asif9876 - 12/12
                      Re: YOU are right..its MOST un... rshearer - 12/12
                         Re: YOU are MOST unfair elojpx - 13/12
                            Re: YOU are MOST unfair FlyingByte - 13/12
                      Re: YOU are right..its MOST un... FlyingByte - 12/12
                      Re: YOU are right..its MOST un... skytraveller - 12/12
                      Re: YOU are right..its MOST un... Pauly - 13/12
                         Re: YOU are right..its MOST un... asif9876 - 13/12
                            Re: YOU are right..its MOST un... jardit - 13/12
                               Re: YOU are right..its MOST un... asif9876 - 13/12
                                  Re: YOU are right..its MOST un... asif9876 - 13/12
                                  Re: YOU are right..its MOST un... thebean - 13/12
                                     Re: YOU are right..its MOST un... asif9876 - 13/12
                                        Re: YOU are right..its MOST un... btm - 13/12
                                           Re: YOU are right..its MOST un... asif9876 - 13/12
                                           Re: YOU are right..its MOST un... Den-ny - 16/12
                                              Re: YOU are right..its MOST un... skytraveller - 16/12
                               Re: YOU are right..its MOST un... globalw2 - 13/12
       YOU are now running a business... FlyingByte - 11/12
          Re: YOU are now running a busi... asif9876 - 11/12
             Re: YOU are now running a busi... jojo - 11/12
                Re: YOU are now running a busi... asif9876 - 12/12
                   Re: YOU are now running a busi... btm - 12/12
                      Re: YOU are now running a busi... asif9876 - 12/12
                         Re: YOU are now running a busi... jacksjpt - 12/12
                            Re: YOU are now running a busi... asif9876 - 12/12
                               Re: YOU are now running a busi... jacksjpt - 12/12
                                  Re: YOU are now running a busi... asif9876 - 12/12
                                     Re: YOU are now running a busi... jacksjpt - 12/12
                               Re: YOU are now running a busi... thebean - 12/12
                                  Re: YOU are now running a busi... asif9876 - 12/12
                                     Re: YOU are now running a busi... freewheelin - 12/12
                                        Re: YOU are now running a busi... jacksjpt - 12/12
                                           Re: YOU are now running a busi... asif9876 - 13/12
                                              Re: YOU are now running a busi... jacksjpt - 13/12
                                                 Re: YOU are now running a busi... asif9876 - 13/12
                                                    Re: YOU are now running a busi... jacksjpt - 13/12
                                                       Re: YOU are now running a busi... asif9876 - 13/12
                                                 Re: YOU are now running a busi... skytraveller - 14/12
                                        Re: YOU are now running a busi... asif9876 - 13/12
                                           Re: YOU are now running a busi... freewheelin - 13/12
                                              Re: YOU are now running a busi... asif9876 - 13/12
                                                 Re: YOU are now running a busi... freewheelin - 13/12
                                                    Re: YOU are now running a busi... asif9876 - 13/12
                                                       Re: YOU are now running a busi... freewheelin - 13/12
                                                          Re: YOU are now running a busi... asif9876 - 13/12
                                                             Re: YOU are now running a busi... freewheelin - 13/12
                                                                Re: YOU are now running a busi... asif9876 - 13/12
                                                                   Re: YOU are now running a busi... richard_marsh2 - 13/12
                                                                      Re: YOU are now running a busi... asif9876 - 13/12
                                                                Right of substitution was Re: ... skytraveller - 14/12
                                                       Re: YOU are now running a busi... skytraveller - 14/12
                                                 Re: YOU are now running a busi... Den-ny - 16/12
                                           Re: YOU are now running a busi... thebean - 13/12
                                              Re: YOU are now running a busi... asif9876 - 13/12
                                                 Re: YOU are now running a busi... skytraveller - 14/12
                                           Re: YOU are now running a busi... PAULSC - 13/12
                                              Re: YOU are now running a busi... asif9876 - 13/12
                                     Re: YOU are now running a busi... skytraveller - 12/12
                                        Re: YOU are now running a busi... asif9876 - 13/12
                                           Re: YOU are now running a busi... PAULSC - 13/12
                                              Re: YOU are now running a busi... asif9876 - 13/12
                                              Re: YOU are now running a busi... Den-ny - 16/12
                                           Re: YOU are now running a busi... skytraveller - 13/12
                                              Re: YOU are now running a busi... asif9876 - 13/12
                                              Re: YOU are now running a busi... Den-ny - 16/12
                   Re: YOU are now running a busi... jtrusc123 - 12/12
                   IT AIN'T THE CIVIL SERVICE jojo - 12/12
                   Re: YOU are now running a busi... cos - 13/12
             Re: YOU are now running a busi... jmwsys - 12/12
                Lol asif9876 - 12/12
                   They may do PAULSC - 12/12
                      Re: They may do asif9876 - 12/12
                         What is a business? PAULSC - 12/12
                            Re: What is a business? asif9876 - 12/12
                               Re: What is a business? NickWoolf - 13/12
                Re: YOU are now running a busi... Den-ny - 16/12
          Re: YOU are now running a busi... Harrison-Andrew - 11/12
             Re: YOU are now running a busi... FlyingByte - 11/12
       Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter Harrison-Andrew - 11/12
          Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter skytraveller - 12/12
       Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter Gnashmills - 12/12
       Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter stillington - 12/12
          Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter skytraveller - 12/12
             Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter garya99 - 12/12
                Asking the general public? jojo - 13/12
                   Re: Asking the general public? garya99 - 14/12
                      new concepts jojo - 15/12
                Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter skytraveller - 14/12
             Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter Den-ny - 16/12
          Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter asif9876 - 13/12
             Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter stillington - 13/12
                Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter asif9876 - 13/12
                   Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter stillington - 13/12
             Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter skytraveller - 14/12
       Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter amichals - 13/12
          Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter asif9876 - 13/12
             Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter amichals - 13/12
                Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter asif9876 - 13/12
    However is taxation really the... brianc - 12/12
       Seven Handy Hints For Hard-Up ... brianc - 12/12
          Re: Seven Handy Hints For Hard... asif9876 - 12/12
             Re: Seven Handy Hints For Hard... brianc - 12/12
                Re: Seven Handy Hints For Hard... asif9876 - 12/12
                   "It's not just the economy, st... brianc - 12/12
       Re: However is taxation really... kazakh - 12/12
          Re: However is taxation really... brianc - 12/12
             GO AWAY (edited) rshearer - 12/12
                Re: GO AWAY brianc - 12/12
             Whilst I understand what you a... Gnashmills - 12/12
                It's not the economy stupid ..... brianc - 12/12
                   How does that relate to my pos... Gnashmills - 12/12
                      Re: How does that relate to my... brianc - 12/12
                         Re: How does that relate to my... Simon Banton - 12/12
             Re: However is taxation really... kazakh - 12/12
             Re: However is taxation really... skytraveller - 12/12
    "Relevant Tax Year" question sebrose - 12/12
       Re: "Relevant Tax Year" questi... PAULSC - 12/12
    Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter richard_marsh2 - 12/12
       Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter jeffbrow - 12/12
    Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter pmt32577 - 12/12
       Re: Qdos: Coo-ee Mr Shifter skytraveller - 12/12
    As I've been saying for years ... brianc - 13/12
    Re: You can Legally Avoid the ... miserableoldsod - 14/12

Copyright 1999-2018, Shout99.com | All Rights Reserved
Privacy Notice and Terms of Use
 

Advertisements
advert
advert
advert
advert